Embedded Files
Some R&D Incentives are Going Unclaimed Due to Psychological Barriers, Misconceptions & Fears
We used to constantly hear about how UK government R&D tax credit incentives, were being left on the table with countless eligible companies, particularly Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (SMEs), failing to claim their R&D tax relief.
It’s unpopular to say this now, since HMRC’s crackdown on compliance but it’s still likely that there are genuine claimants that are not making claims. This isn't always due to a lack of awareness of the scheme. I’ve noticed that there is a fascinating array of psychological barriers, misconceptions, and fears some of which have been exasperated by recent heavy-handed HMRC compliance processes. Understanding these underlying factors is crucial for encouraging more businesses to embrace the relief where they can rightfully claim. Here are some of the reasons I’ve come across.
"We're Not Innovative Enough": The Imposter Syndrome of R&D
Perhaps the most pervasive psychological barrier is the belief that a company's work isn't "innovative enough" to qualify for R&D tax relief. Many business owners equate R&D solely with groundbreaking scientific discoveries in pristine laboratories or the creation of entirely new technologies.
The "Eureka!" Myth: They envision a "Eureka!" moment leading to a patentable invention, rather than the often incremental, trial-and-error process that characterises much legitimate R&D. They overlook the systematic investigation undertaken to resolve genuine scientific or technological uncertainties in their own products, processes, or services.
Internal Benchmarking: Companies often compare themselves to industry giants with dedicated R&D departments and multi-million-pound budgets. This internal comparison fosters an "imposter syndrome," where their own significant, yet smaller-scale, advancements feel inadequate. They forget that R&D for tax purposes isn't about global novelty, but about overcoming technical challenges that aren't readily deducible to a competent professional in their field.
This self-deprecating view prevents them from even exploring the possibility, leaving RDEC benefits unclaimed.
Fear of HMRC Scrutiny: The "Red Flag" Anxiety
Another significant psychological hurdle is an underlying fear of HMRC scrutiny which has grown in recent years. The very mention of a tax authority can trigger anxiety, and the thought of an R&D claim potentially flagging their business for an enquiry can be enough to deter otherwise eligible companies.
Misconceptions about "Risk": Many believe that claiming R&D tax relief automatically increases their chances of a full HMRC audit. While it's true that R&D claims are subject to review, a well-prepared claim with robust documentation and a clear technical narrative significantly mitigates this risk. The fear can be disproportionate to the actual likelihood of a challenging enquiry for a compliant business.
Time and Resource Drain: Beyond the fear of an adverse outcome, there's the apprehension about the process of an enquiry. Business owners imagine lengthy, intrusive investigations that divert precious time and resources away from their core operations. This perceived administrative burden can outweigh the perceived benefit of the tax relief. If a claim is well compiled in the first instance, dealing with an enquiry should not be over burdensome, although there have been some recent instances of HMRC making the process unduly lengthy.
Ignorance of the Process: This fear is often exacerbated by a lack of understanding of what an R&D enquiry entails. When demystified by experienced consultants, the process often proves less daunting than initially imagined.
This anxiety leads to a "better safe than sorry" mentality, where companies opt out of claiming to avoid potential hassle, thereby foregoing significant financial benefits.
Complexity and Time Investment: The "Too Hard" Mentality
Even if companies acknowledge their work might qualify and they're less fearful of HMRC, the perceived complexity and time investment can be a deterrent.
"Too Busy" Syndrome: Entrepreneurs and business leaders, particularly in SMEs, are constantly juggling multiple responsibilities. The task of identifying R&D projects, quantifying costs, and writing technical narratives can seem like a monumental undertaking they simply don't have time for.
Lack of Internal Expertise: Many smaller companies lack a dedicated finance team or in-house technical writer. The thought of navigating complex tax legislation and preparing detailed technical reports themselves can feel overwhelming, leading to procrastination or outright abandonment.
Underestimating External Help: They may underestimate the value and efficiency of engaging specialist R&D tax consultants, believing it to be an unnecessary expense or that the process is simple enough to handle internally (which can lead to poorly prepared claims).
This perception of complexity creates a psychological block, leading businesses to conclude that the effort isn't worth the reward, even when the financial benefits could be transformative.
Overcoming the Barriers: A Shift in Perspective
Addressing these psychological barriers requires more than just explaining the rules; it requires a shift in perspective.
Redefining R&D: Consultants and industry bodies need to continually reframe R&D as a common, everyday activity within businesses, focusing on problem-solving and systematic improvement rather than just "invention."
Demystifying HMRC Enquiries: Providing clear, transparent information about the HMRC enquiry process, emphasising the importance of good record-keeping, and offering support can alleviate the fear around claiming.
Highlighting the Benefits (Beyond Tax): Emphasising how R&D tax relief can fuel further innovation, protect cash flow, and contribute to long-term business growth can motivate companies to overcome initial hesitations.
The Evolving Role of the R&D Consultant
As the R&D tax consultancy landscape matures, a shift is occurring. With fewer "bad actors," reputable consultants should have a role to play in helping businesses overcome the psychological barriers to claiming R&D tax relief. They can act as trusted partners, bridging the gap between a company's innovative work and HMRC's strict criteria. Their combined technical and tax expertise allows them to help companies identify genuine scientific and technological uncertainties that internal teams might overlook.
From Fear to Confidence
Consultants also play a critical role in demystifying the process. They provide the essential reassurance that a claim is robust, well-documented, and capable of withstanding HMRC scrutiny. This proactive approach helps businesses avoid unnecessary internal strain and ensures they don't miss out on valuable relief. For a business, the key is due diligence; choosing a firm that prioritises compliant, well-supported claims over quick, aggressive wins.
By understanding and proactively addressing the psychology behind why companies don't claim, consultants and external tax accountants can help unlock the full potential of the new RDEC incentives, fostering a more innovative and prosperous business landscape—which is, after all, the ultimate goal of the government's policy.
Page updated
Google Sites
Report abuse